Skip to content
Junior Secondary lessons

JSS 3 / English Studies / Third term

Reading Arguments Critically

15 min3 quiz questions

Your learning goals

By the end, you can…

  • Distinguish a claim from supporting evidence.
  • Evaluate whether evidence is relevant and reliable.

Let’s discover

Something new to learn

1

A claim is a statement someone wants you to accept. Evidence is information offered to support it.

2

‘Our library needs more seats’ is a claim. A count showing pupils waiting for seats at busy times could be relevant evidence.

3

An opinion is a judgement or belief. It can be reasonable, but it is not automatically proof.

Look at that! You’ve learned something new.

Hands-on tool

Sound cards

Tap a card to hear the letter and a word that starts with it. Build your own word below.

…

A closer look

Let’s understand it together

Check who produced the evidence, when it was collected and whether it directly supports the claim. A confident voice does not make a claim true.

A strong response fairly considers another viewpoint and explains why its conclusion follows from the evidence.

Words to know

Claim
A statement presented for acceptance.
Evidence
Information supporting or challenging a claim.

Explore an example

Let’s work through it

  1. 1.

    Claim: the reading room needs more seats.

  2. 2.

    Evidence: on three afternoons, six pupils had no seat while all seats were occupied.

  3. 3.

    Consider alternatives, such as different opening times, before proposing more seats.

Try it yourself

Put your learning into practice

You’ll need: A notebook, a pencil and a learning partner if available.

  1. 1

    Write a claim about a fictional school.

  2. 2

    List information you would need to test it, without inventing real survey results.

  3. 3

    Write a short paragraph that separates claim, possible evidence and conclusion.

Remember this

The key idea

Ask what is claimed, what supports it and whether that support is relevant and trustworthy.

Your turn

Quiz time!

0 of 3 answered

Question 1

Which is evidence about seating?

Question 2

An opinion is automatically proof.

Question 3

Good evidence should be…

Keep your curiosity going

Keep building your knowledge

All Junior Secondary lessons